Reading As A Reader, Reading As A Writer, Reading As An Editor

I picked up a book last week. My absolute favourite author in the world and yet there are several books by him I haven’t read yet. One of them was a movie adaptation from the well known Hammer Horror franchise.

Purple present from OpenClipartI picked up this book because it was written by this particular chap and I opened it up with the same glee one feels when opening up a Christmas or birthday present.


I read the prologue and felt a little strange. I thought; ‘this isn’t his usual style is it? Maybe I haven’t read enough of his knew stuff to know how he writes these days. I should keep going.’ So I read chapter one. Then I thought; ‘this is still a bit weird. That word choice was a bit clumsy, this sentence is poorly constructed. Hell, that was utterly the wrong adjective to use considering the tone he’s trying to convey.’ And I put the book down.

I’ve never put one of this guy’s books down before. Ever. I adore and respect his work too much and I only managed to leave the book on the table for about two hours before I wanted to give it another try.

Half way through and I still felt uncomfortable. That’s when I realised, for the first time, that I’m ruined as a reader. Now and forever more, I won’t be able to read a book without unconsciously editing or critiquing it. That understanding upset me so much that I had to take another break from the book.

After a day or two, after promising myself that I would make a concious effort not not to critique it in my mind, I finished reading it. But only just.

I’ve been working very hard at critiques lately. Not only is it part of The Write Feeling, but it is a valuable process to go through as a writer, because it helps you learn. It prods you to look at your own work with a far more critical eye and that is key. Before things like the Phoenix Writers, the Leicester Writing School and the Sunday Snippets Blog Hop there was a huge part of my skill set missing. Not just in giving a critique, but receiving one. Understanding that the comments are not an all out attack on me, or my precious babies, but a genuine attempt to make said babies as strong as they possibly can be.

I suppose, in knowing this, it’s only natural that my critiquing eye has become sharper, but to find myself mentally checking off issues in the words of an established writer, one that I have loved and respected for years is incredible!

Geology symbol from OpenClipArtIs it natural progression? Is this just what happens when one goes deeper into a hobby or an interest? Certainly when I studied geology at university, I never imagined that my holiday life would be wrecked forever more. I can’t walk passed any exposed strata without having a feel, a scratch (not of me, of the rock! …dirty!) and a guess at what it is. If I had my tools with me I would take dip and strike measurements! With that already in my past I should have suspected something similar might happen, but it still came as a surprise to me.

As you work on your own books, do you find that you think about writing differently? Do you read someone else’s work and start picking at it? Do you look at authors you’ve known and loved and find yourself surprised at what you read?

Don’t get me wrong, I still love this guy and will continue to buy his books, but this makes me dread my bi annual reading of The Lord Of The Rings. o.O

About Ileandra Young

I'm a thirty-*mumbles* year old (purple loving, cheese worshipping) author of fantasy, juggling a pair of beautiful twin boys with my burning desire to make up stories and write them all down. When I get the chance, I play games, listen to music, and in days long past I even ran a radio show. Though I occasionally write non-fiction, my heart lives in fantasy and my debut novel, Silk Over Razor Blades is now available through Amazon along with part two of the trilogy, Walking The Razor's Edge.
This entry was posted in Ileandra's Posts and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Reading As A Reader, Reading As A Writer, Reading As An Editor

  1. It happens all the bloody time. It can be a real effort to turn my internal editor off. However it means that when I do read something that doesn’t keep jolting me out of the story with typos, grammar mistakes and clunky phrasing, I absolutely devour it.


  2. jmmcdowell says:

    Oh, yes. It is SO hard to read simply for enjoyment now that I’m writing. But then, when I see commercially successful authors doing all the things new writers are told NOT to do, I also get cranky with the double standard!


    • It’s not fair, is it?
      I guess all it shows is that you have to be well known/trusted before you’re allowed to break the rules. >.< Apparently because you 'know' which rules 'can' be broken and which ones 'should' be broken.
      Crap if you ask me… it just irks me.


  3. Not happened to me yet but i do notice of book is 1st or 3rd person now lol- give it time and il be noticing more 😦


  4. Pingback: Raven’s January Indie eBook Review: Literal Fantasies | Writing: A Conversation Without Interruptions

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s